What a board investigative subpoena for patient records means in California
A board investigative subpoena is a formal demand from a California licensing board for documents, often patient records, during an investigation. If you are a physician, dentist, nurse, pharmacist, psychologist or therapist, it may be the first notice you receive that someone has raised a concern about your practice.
Receiving a subpoena does not mean the board has found misconduct. It means investigators are gathering evidence before deciding whether further action is warranted. Your response should account for the records requested, the deadline and your patients’ privacy rights.
These issues affect health care professionals throughout California, including Sacramento, Stockton and San Joaquin County. Understanding the board’s authority and your obligations can help you respond without creating separate licensing or confidentiality problems.
Key takeaways
- California licensing boards can issue investigative subpoenas before filing formal disciplinary charges.
- Patient records remain protected by California constitutional privacy rights and applicable state and federal laws.
- A patient-authorized records request, an investigative subpoena and a court order carry different legal requirements.
- Physicians can face civil penalties of up to $10,000 for failing to comply with certain medical records requests.
- Original medical records must be preserved. Do not conceal alterations, destroy documents or recreate missing records as originals.
- A subpoena may be challenged on valid legal grounds, but ignoring it does not preserve an objection.
Why California licensing boards request patient records
Patient records often provide the primary evidence in an investigation involving treatment, prescribing, billing or professional conduct. Investigators review the documentation to determine what happened and whether the licensee complied with applicable standards.
The Medical Board of California identifies medical records reviews, witness interviews, investigative subpoenas and expert evaluations as possible steps in its investigative process. Its investigative work involves the Department of Consumer Affairs’ Health Quality Investigation Unit.
Other agencies, including the Dental Board of California, Board of Psychology, Board of Registered Nursing (BRN), California State Board of Pharmacy and Board of Behavioral Sciences, investigate complaints under their respective practice acts.
A patient complaint is not the only reason an investigation may begin. Information can also come from law enforcement, another regulatory agency, a health care facility or prescribing data. For physicians, the state’s Controlled Substance Utilization Review and Evaluation System, commonly called CURES, can provide information relevant to investigations involving controlled substances.
The subpoena may identify the patients and records sought without explaining every allegation. That makes the wording of the request particularly important.
What records might the board request?
The documents requested depend on the nature of the investigation. A prescribing complaint may require different information from an investigation involving patient consent or the quality of treatment.
An investigative subpoena may seek:
- Patient charts, progress notes and treatment histories
- Medication orders, prescribing records and pharmacy documentation
- Laboratory results, imaging and diagnostic reports
- Referral letters, consultation notes and discharge instructions
- Consent forms, patient communications and portal messages
- Billing records, invoices and insurance claim documentation
- Electronic health record audit trails and related system information
A demand for medical records does not automatically establish that the board is entitled to every document in a patient’s file. The subpoena’s scope, the investigation’s purpose and applicable privacy protections must be considered together.
Where California licensing boards get subpoena authority
California Government Code sections 11180 through 11191 establish investigative powers for state departments. Section 11181 authorizes subpoenas for documents and testimony concerning matters within an agency’s investigative authority.
Government Code section 11184 requires investigative subpoenas to comply with constitutional protections. These provisions allow an authorized agency to gather evidence before an administrative accusation or hearing is filed, but the agency must remain within the limits of its statutory authority.
An investigative subpoena is different from a subpoena issued during civil litigation. It may arise entirely within a licensing board investigation, without an existing court case.
Records request, investigative subpoena or court order
Three types of documents commonly appear during licensing investigations. Understanding which one you received is necessary because the governing deadlines and consequences can differ.
- Records request with patient authorization. The board requests medical records and includes written authorization from the patient or an authorized representative. Certain licensing statutes impose specific production deadlines and penalties for noncompliance.
- Administrative investigative subpoena. The agency demands documents under its investigative authority. Patient authorization may be absent, which can raise questions concerning privacy, relevance and the scope of disclosure.
- Court order enforcing a subpoena. If a dispute reaches superior court, a judge may order production. Failure to obey the order can result in additional legal consequences, including contempt or penalties authorized by applicable statutes.
The deadline printed on an investigative subpoena should not be confused with a separate statutory deadline governing patient-authorized records requests. Review the document and the applicable law before determining how to respond.
How patient privacy limits a board investigative subpoena
Article I, section 1 of the California Constitution protects individual privacy, including the confidentiality of medical information. The Confidentiality of Medical Information Act also regulates when health care providers may disclose patient records.
Under Civil Code section 56.10, health care providers generally may not disclose medical information without authorization unless a statutory exception applies. Subdivision (b)(4) addresses disclosure compelled by an investigative subpoena issued under the Government Code.
That statutory provision does not remove constitutional privacy protections. Courts may examine whether the agency has sufficient grounds to obtain the records and whether its request intrudes more broadly on patient privacy than the investigation justifies.
Federal privacy requirements may also apply. HIPAA permits certain disclosures for lawful health oversight activities, including professional licensing investigations, subject to its requirements. The existence of a subpoena does not authorize unrestricted disclosure of unrelated patient information.
What California courts have said about patient privacy
California courts have addressed conflicts between licensing board investigations and the confidentiality of patient records for decades.
In Board of Medical Quality Assurance v. Gherardini (1979) 93 Cal.App.3d 669, the Court of Appeal considered the constitutional privacy interests involved when a medical licensing agency sought patient information. The decision recognized that investigative authority must be evaluated alongside those privacy protections.
A more recent decision is Grafilo v. Wolfsohn (2019) 33 Cal.App.5th 1024. The Medical Board was investigating a physician’s prescribing practices and sought records involving five patients.
The investigation included CURES data and an opinion from a medical consultant. After the physician challenged the subpoena, the superior court ordered production of the records. The Court of Appeal reversed because the agency had not established good cause for the subpoena.
The decision illustrates that a licensing board cannot rely solely on its general investigative authority to overcome patient privacy objections. The evidence supporting a demand for confidential records must satisfy the applicable legal standard.
That does not mean every investigative subpoena can be refused. A different investigation, supported by stronger evidence or a more limited request, may justify enforcement. Each dispute requires an examination of the records sought and the facts supporting the board’s demand.
Additional protection for mental health and substance use records
Psychotherapy notes, psychiatric treatment information and certain substance use treatment records may be subject to additional confidentiality requirements.
HIPAA gives special treatment to psychotherapy notes maintained separately from the patient’s general medical record. Certain substance use disorder treatment records are also governed by federal confidentiality regulations under 42 CFR Part 2.
These rules do not apply identically to every mental health record. A psychologist, psychiatrist, marriage and family therapist or clinical social worker should distinguish ordinary treatment documentation from records subject to separate restrictions.
Before disclosing sensitive material, determine whether the subpoena or authorization satisfies the requirements applicable to each record category. A general request for treatment records may not resolve every confidentiality question.
What changes when a patient signs an authorization?
When a patient files a complaint, the licensing board may ask the patient to authorize disclosure of relevant medical records. The agency can then request those records directly from the provider without relying on an investigative subpoena.
Before producing documents, confirm that the authorization identifies the correct patient and provider. Review the signature, applicable dates, records covered and any restrictions stated in the authorization.
If the document is incomplete or its scope is uncertain, request clarification through the appropriate channel. A valid authorization does not permit disclosure of other patients’ records or information outside its lawful scope.
For some professions, a request accompanied by written patient authorization also triggers statutory production deadlines. Those requirements must be considered separately from the board’s administrative subpoena authority.
Deadlines and penalties for medical records requests in California
Records production deadlines depend on the licensing agency, the document issued and the person or facility responsible for maintaining the records.
For physicians, Business and Professions Code section 2225.5 establishes specific requirements for certified medical records requested by the Medical Board. The statute distinguishes obligations imposed on physician licensees from those imposed on covered health care facilities.
The 15-day deadline for physicians
Under section 2225.5(a)(1), a physician who receives a request for certified patient medical records accompanied by the patient’s written authorization generally must produce those records within 15 days after receiving the request and authorization.
A physician who fails to comply may face a civil penalty of $1,000 per day after the 15th day, up to $10,000. The statute provides an exception when the physician is unable to produce the records within that period for good cause.
This penalty applies to the type of request described in the statute. It should not be treated as an automatic penalty for every investigative subpoena issued by a California licensing board.
Separate deadlines for hospitals and clinics
Section 2225.5(a)(2) establishes requirements for covered health care facilities. When the board provides the required records request, patient authorization and statutory notice, a facility generally has 30 days to produce certified records.
For covered facilities with electronic health records, the statute establishes a 15-day production period under the specified conditions.
Failure to comply can result in civil penalties of up to $1,000 per day, with a maximum of $10,000, subject to the statute’s good cause provisions.
The law defines which clinics and health facilities fall within these requirements. Not every private practice, medical office or employer is necessarily covered by the facility provisions.
Penalties for violating a court order
Section 2225.5 also addresses failures to comply with court orders enforcing medical records subpoenas.
For physician licensees, failure to obey an applicable court order can result in civil penalties of $1,000 per day after the court’s production deadline, up to $10,000, unless the order is determined to be unlawful or invalid.
The statute also establishes misdemeanor penalties for certain violations and treats a physician licensee’s failure or refusal to comply with such a court order as unprofessional conduct. Separate provisions address health care facilities.
Other licensing boards may have different statutes governing records production and noncompliance. Check the law applicable to your profession rather than assuming the Medical Board’s requirements apply to every health care license.
If a deadline cannot be met, address the problem before it passes. Request any extension in writing and document the circumstances. Neither an extension request nor an objection should be assumed to suspend a deadline without an applicable legal basis or confirmation.
What to do when a board investigative subpoena arrives
Begin by identifying the agency’s request and securing the relevant records. Avoid providing explanations about the underlying complaint before you understand the allegations and have reviewed the available documentation.
The following steps can help establish an organized response.
- Record the date of receipt. Keep the subpoena, envelope, attachments and accompanying correspondence. Identify the production deadline and required delivery method.
- Confirm the issuing agency. Identify the licensing board, assigned investigator, person who issued the subpoena and designated location for production.
- List the requested information. Note the patients, treatment dates, document categories and any electronic data specifically requested.
- Preserve original records. Secure paper and electronic records against unauthorized changes, deletion or routine destruction.
- Identify the records custodian. Determine whether the documents are maintained by your practice, an employer, a hospital or another entity.
- Review confidentiality concerns. Check for patient authorization, specially protected information and requests that may extend beyond the investigation’s lawful scope.
- Obtain legal advice when appropriate. A licensing attorney can evaluate whether production, clarification, an objection or another response is warranted before the deadline.
Some professional liability policies provide coverage for licensing board matters or require notice of an investigation. Review your policy terms to determine whether and when notification is required.
Why preserving the original medical records is essential
Once you know records are being requested or investigated, preserve them in their existing condition. Do not remove unfavorable information, change treatment dates, rewrite previous entries or create documents that falsely appear to have been prepared during the original treatment.
For physicians, Business and Professions Code section 2262 identifies certain fraudulent alterations of medical records as unprofessional conduct. Other health care boards have separate documentation and professional conduct requirements.
A legitimate correction differs from an undisclosed alteration. Proper late entries should follow the applicable recordkeeping rules, accurately identify when the correction was made and preserve the original information where required.
Electronic records management also needs attention. Routine deletion schedules, system upgrades and storage transfers should not result in the loss of information that must be preserved for an investigation.
Electronic health records and audit trails
An electronic health record system may retain information that does not appear on a standard chart printout. Audit trails can identify when entries were created, accessed or modified, depending on the system.
Patient messages, scanned documents and medication information may also be stored separately from ordinary progress notes.
If a subpoena requests audit trails or metadata, coordinate with the appropriate records custodian, electronic health record vendor or authorized technical staff. The goal is to preserve and export responsive information accurately without changing the underlying data.
Keep an inventory of the electronic documents produced, including file names, transmission dates and any relevant certification information.
How long physicians must retain medical records in California
Medical record retention rules can become relevant when a subpoena requests older documents or information from a previous practice.
Under Business and Professions Code section 2266, physicians and surgeons must maintain adequate and accurate records relating to services provided to their patients for at least seven years after the last date of service. Failure to meet that requirement constitutes unprofessional conduct.
The seven-year requirement took effect on January 1, 2024. Other applicable laws or contractual obligations may require longer retention periods, depending on the records and circumstances.
Retention requirements for dentists, psychologists, nurses and other professionals may differ. Rules involving minors, health care facilities or particular treatment records can also require separate review.
The fact that records are old does not establish that they were properly destroyed. Determine which retention requirements applied and whether any duty to preserve the documents continued beyond the ordinary retention period.
Can you object to a California licensing board subpoena?
Yes. A licensee or records custodian may challenge an investigative subpoena when there is a valid legal basis.
Common objections concern requests that exceed the agency’s authority, demand unrelated patient records, cover an unreasonable period or seek confidential information without sufficient supporting grounds.
A written objection should identify the specific concern and its legal basis. An attorney may contact the investigator or assigned deputy attorney general to seek clarification, limit the production or address appropriate confidentiality protections.
For example, a request for several years of complete records involving numerous patients may raise different concerns from a subpoena limited to one patient’s treatment over a short period.
The appropriate response depends on the investigation, the evidence supporting the request and the privacy interests involved. An objection does not automatically cancel the subpoena.
What happens if the board seeks court enforcement?
Under Government Code section 11187, the agency may petition superior court to compel compliance with an investigative subpoena.
The petition may be filed in a county where the investigation or hearing is pending or where the subpoena designates testimony or document production, subject to the statute’s requirements. The proper venue is not automatically Sacramento County merely because a state licensing board is based there.
Government Code section 11188 describes the court process for requiring the recipient to explain why the subpoena has not been followed.
The court can consider whether the subpoena was properly issued and whether it satisfies applicable legal and constitutional requirements. When patient privacy is disputed, the agency’s supporting evidence may become central to the court’s decision.
Section 11187(d) also provides that the validity of certain objections resulting in refusal to comply is determined through the agency’s enforcement proceeding. The manner and timing of an objection therefore deserve careful legal review.
Ignoring the subpoena does not protect confidential records from judicial enforcement. A documented response based on the applicable law is different from simply refusing to communicate with the agency.
Should you contact the patient about the investigation?
Communications with a patient after receiving a board subpoena can raise additional concerns. Ordinary treatment communications may remain appropriate, but discussions intended to influence a complaint or discourage cooperation with investigators present separate risks.
For physicians, Business and Professions Code section 2234(h) identifies conduct intended to cause a patient or authorized representative to rescind consent for the release of medical records to the board or the Department of Consumer Affairs’ Health Quality Investigation Unit as unprofessional conduct.
Section 2234(i) also addresses attempts to dissuade, intimidate or tamper with patients and witnesses to prevent reporting or testimony concerning a licensee.
Do not ask a patient to withdraw a complaint or revoke authorization for the purpose of interfering with an investigation. If a communication concerning the investigation is necessary, determine its proper scope and purpose before proceeding.
What if your employer or hospital holds the records?
Many physicians, nurses and other health care professionals work in hospitals, medical groups or clinics that maintain the official patient records. In those settings, the organization may receive and respond to the subpoena through its records custodian.
This arrangement is common among professionals working in Sacramento, Roseville, Elk Grove and Stockton, where large hospital systems operate alongside independent practices.
Determine who received the subpoena and who has authority to produce the requested documents. Larger organizations may direct the request to a privacy officer, compliance department or legal team.
The investigation may concern your individual care even when the employer controls the records. However, that does not necessarily give you an independent right to obtain, download or retain copies for your personal defense.
Patient privacy laws, professional responsibilities and employer policies can restrict access. A licensing attorney can help determine how to obtain relevant documents lawfully and communicate with the records custodian.
This becomes particularly important when an employer’s interests differ from those of the individual licensee.
Records held by a former employer
A subpoena may involve treatment provided at a practice where you no longer work. Access to the former employer’s electronic records may have ended, or the practice may have transferred its records to another custodian.
Identify the appropriate records holder as early as possible. Make necessary requests in writing and retain correspondence documenting attempts to locate the material.
If delays involving another entity may affect the subpoena deadline, address that issue promptly through the appropriate legal or administrative process.
Do not assume that your former employment gives you unrestricted access to patient information. Any request for copies should account for applicable confidentiality requirements.
What if patient records are missing or unavailable?
Records may be difficult to locate after a practice closes, a medical group changes software or a storage provider transfers older files.
When requested documents cannot be found, document the search. Identify the record systems, storage locations, custodians and other sources checked.
Preserve correspondence or other evidence explaining what happened to the missing material. If records were transferred or destroyed under a retention policy, determine whether documentation of that action exists.
Do not recreate a missing chart from memory and present it as an original treatment record. A later factual explanation must be identified accurately rather than disguised as contemporaneous documentation.
Missing records can raise questions about compliance with retention and documentation duties. They do not, by themselves, establish that the underlying patient care allegation is true.
A response should accurately describe the available information and any limitations on production, with appropriate legal review when necessary.
How to organize medical records for production
When disclosure is legally required or otherwise appropriate, organize the responsive documents so they can be identified and accounted for.
Confirm the patients, dates and record categories covered by the request. Avoid including unrelated information unless its disclosure is otherwise required.
Records may need to be certified by the licensee or responsible health care facility. Under Business and Professions Code section 2225.5(f), certified medical records are authenticated on a form prescribed by the Medical Board.
Other agencies may establish different certification procedures. Follow the applicable requirements rather than assuming an ordinary photocopy or electronic export satisfies the request.
Page numbering, including Bates numbering, can help identify individual documents during later correspondence or proceedings. A brief cover letter may describe the records produced, the date of production and any agreed limitations.
Keep an exact copy of the production and reliable proof of delivery. Sensitive medical information should be transmitted through an appropriately secure method.
Communications accompanying the records should remain factual. A production cover letter is generally not the place to offer an extensive defense of the underlying treatment unless that explanation is specifically appropriate.
What happens after the board receives patient records?
Records production is often one stage of a broader licensing investigation. The board may examine the documents internally, request additional information or refer the material to a professional reviewer.
For Medical Board quality-of-care investigations, a medical expert may evaluate whether the treatment met the applicable professional standard. Investigators can also interview the physician, patient, coworkers or other witnesses.
The information obtained from records may influence subsequent questions and investigative decisions. A request for documents does not guarantee that an interview will occur.
Our article on California licensing board investigations and interviews addresses what professionals may encounter when investigators request statements or schedule interviews.
After reviewing the evidence, the board may close the matter if a violation is not established or the evidence does not support disciplinary action. Other investigations may lead to additional review, a citation or referral for formal proceedings.
The available outcomes depend on the board’s authority and the facts of the investigation.
Does a subpoena mean a formal accusation is coming?
No. An investigative subpoena is a means of gathering evidence, not a formal determination that professional misconduct occurred.
An accusation is a separate administrative document alleging grounds for disciplinary action against a licensee. If the board files one, the professional generally has a limited period to respond and may have the right to request a hearing.
Depending on the governing law and circumstances, the proceeding may involve an administrative law judge, settlement discussions or a contested evidentiary hearing.
Our discussion of the California administrative law process explains how disciplinary accusations can proceed through administrative hearings and judicial review.
Because those proceedings have separate response requirements, do not assume that meeting the subpoena deadline will satisfy later obligations if an accusation is filed.
How long can a California licensing board investigation take?
There is no single timetable for every licensing board investigation. The time required depends on the records involved, the allegations, available evidence and investigative workload.
Obtaining and producing records may take days or weeks. Expert evaluations, witness interviews and additional records requests can extend the investigation for several months or longer.
Cases involving multiple patients, extensive prescribing histories or records held by different facilities may require more time.
After completing production, maintain a record of communications with the board. Keep copies of notices and promptly update your official address of record when required.
A long period without contact does not necessarily indicate that the investigation has closed. When appropriate, an attorney can contact the assigned investigator to ask about the case’s status.
Board investigative subpoenas in Sacramento and San Joaquin County
Several California health care licensing boards operate within the Department of Consumer Affairs, which is based in Sacramento. These state agencies investigate licensed professionals throughout California rather than only those practicing near their offices.
A physician practicing in Midtown Sacramento, a dentist in Elk Grove or a psychologist in Roseville may receive an investigative subpoena from the same state agency responsible for professionals elsewhere in California.
The same rules can affect licensed professionals in Stockton, Lodi, Tracy and Manteca. A nurse working in San Joaquin County may be subject to a BRN investigation, while a pharmacist or physician in the same area may answer to a different licensing board.
The governing law generally comes from the applicable state statutes and professional practice act, not the county where the professional works.
Local circumstances can still affect records production. Hospital systems, independent practices and multi-location medical groups may use different procedures for receiving subpoenas, identifying custodians and authorizing disclosure.
Judicial enforcement proceedings may also occur in a county authorized by the Government Code. The proper court depends on statutory venue provisions and the circumstances of the subpoena.
For Sacramento and San Joaquin County professionals, reviewing these requirements early can help identify whether the subpoena should be handled directly by the licensee, through an employer or with assistance from counsel.
Common questions about board investigative subpoenas
Do I have to comply with a board investigative subpoena?
A properly issued investigative subpoena requires a timely legal response. Depending on the circumstances, you may need to produce the requested records or raise a valid objection through the appropriate process. If the subpoena is not followed, the board may seek enforcement in superior court. Do not assume that concerns about privacy or scope automatically suspend the deadline.
Can a licensing board get patient records without consent?
Yes, under certain circumstances. California licensing agencies may obtain patient records through lawful investigative subpoenas without a signed patient authorization. Constitutional privacy protections still apply, and the board may need to establish sufficient grounds for enforcement if the demand is challenged. The decision in Grafilo v. Wolfsohn illustrates those limits.
Can I refuse a subpoena because the records are confidential?
Confidentiality alone does not invalidate every investigative subpoena. California law recognizes certain disclosures compelled by lawful administrative subpoenas while protecting patient privacy. A challenge may be appropriate when the agency exceeds its authority, requests unrelated information or fails to satisfy applicable legal requirements. The specific grounds should be evaluated before withholding records.
Can I correct a chart error after receiving a subpoena?
Do not conceal, backdate or improperly replace an existing record. Legitimate corrections must comply with professional documentation requirements and accurately identify when the entry was made. Original information and relevant audit history should be preserved as required. Obtain advice about handling a known error rather than making a change that could be interpreted as misleading.
What if my hospital holds the requested records?
The hospital or medical group’s records custodian may be responsible for responding to the subpoena. Determine who received the request and who has authority to produce the material. If the investigation concerns your individual care, you may need lawful access to relevant records for your defense. Coordinate through authorized channels instead of retaining patient information without permission.
What if I already submitted records before contacting an attorney?
Keep a complete copy of the documents submitted, together with the accompanying correspondence and proof of delivery. An attorney can review the production, identify any remaining obligations and help address later investigative requests. Do not attempt to alter previously submitted information or make unauthorized disclosures to correct a perceived problem.
Will the board interview me after reviewing the records?
An interview is possible, but not every investigation requires one. The board may evaluate the records, obtain an expert opinion or seek information from other witnesses before determining the next step. If an investigator requests an interview, consider legal advice about your obligations and the issues likely to be discussed before providing a substantive statement.
Should I speak with a licensing attorney before producing records?
Legal review can be useful when a subpoena involves confidential patient information, an unusually broad demand or possible professional discipline. An attorney can evaluate the request, identify relevant deadlines and address appropriate objections or production arrangements. Obtaining representation does not automatically extend a deadline, so a timely review is important.
How our Sacramento licensing defense office can help
The Law Office of Jonathan Turner focuses on California administrative law and professional license defense. Attorney Jonathan Turner has represented California licensed professionals in administrative matters since 1998, including board investigations, disciplinary accusations, administrative hearings and appeals.
We represent physicians, nurses, dentists, pharmacists, psychologists, therapists and other professionals licensed by California state agencies. Our work includes reviewing investigative demands, evaluating potential disciplinary issues and communicating with licensing boards when a response is required.
When a board requests patient records, we can assess the subpoena’s scope, applicable production deadlines and confidentiality concerns. We also help clients prepare for investigative interviews and formal disciplinary proceedings when necessary.
Our Sacramento office is located at 3620 American River Drive, Suite 120, Sacramento, CA 95864. We maintain a second office at 444 W. Ocean Blvd., Suite 800, Long Beach, CA 90802, and represent licensed professionals throughout California, including San Joaquin County.
Speak with a California professional license defense attorney
A board investigative subpoena requires attention, but receiving one does not mean your professional license will be disciplined. The appropriate response depends on the agency’s authority, the records requested and the laws governing your profession.
If you received a subpoena or patient records request from the Medical Board of California, Dental Board, BRN or another licensing agency, we can review the documents and discuss your available options.
Contact the Law Office of Jonathan Turner or call (916) 471-6506 for a free, confidential consultation. We can help you understand the applicable requirements and determine the next steps in responding to the investigation.
This information is provided for general educational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Subpoena requirements, privacy protections and disciplinary procedures vary by licensing agency, profession and individual circumstances.


